Your One-Stop Insurance Shop

MTIA offers a wide variety of insurances and our expert team has the industry knowledge to help you select the right insurance coverage for your particular needs.


We have an in-house team of insurance experts who are dedicated exclusively to personal insurance. We’ve intentionally structured our business to benefit you, our customer. For all your auto, home, life and individual health insurance needs, we’ve got you covered.

 Personal Insurance we offer: 
  • Property | Homeowners, Condos & Renters Policies
  • Motor Vehicles | Automobile, Motorcycle, RVs & ATVs
  • Watercraft | Boats, Yachts & Personal Watercraft
  • Umbrella | Excess Personal Liability
  • Life Insurance | Term & Whole Life Products, No-Lapse Guarantee Universal, Annuities
  • Umbrella Liability
  • And More!


Never again worry about insurance gaps that put your business at risk. We have an in-house team of insurance experts who are dedicated exclusively to the ever changing landscape and expansion of your business.

Commercial Insurance
we offer: 
  • General Liability
  • Commercial Package
  • Commercial Auto
  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial Umbrella
  • Inland Marine
  • Product Liability
  • Employee Practices
    We work with:
    • Manufacturers | Wood, Metal, Paper, Rubber, Plastics
    • Contractors | Commercial & Residential
    • Wholesale Distributors | Durable & Non-durable Goods
    • Self Storage / Mini Warehouse | Customer Goods & Warehouse Legal Liability
    • Retail Products & Services | Main Street Retailers Large & Small
    • Auto Dealers | New & Used, Single or Multiple Location
    • Automotive Services | Auto Repair, Quick Lube, Collision Center, Car Wash, Towing
    • Apartment Buildings | From Duplex to Large Apartment Communities
    • Restaurant & Food Service | Fine Dining, Casual, Franchise & Fast Food
    • Trucking
    • And More!


    Work with our team of life insurance experts to protect the future of your family. We’re able to source coverage from 20+ carriers to build a customized plan that fits your family or business needs.

    Life Insurance we offer: 
    • Term Life
    • Whole Life
    • No-Lapse Guarantee Universal
    • Annuities

    Matthew Trittschuh Insurance Agency

    1230 Lexington Avenue
    Suite 100
    Mansfield, Ohio 44907


    Phone: (419) 775-5758
    Fax: (419)464-9961

    Monday-Friday 9 AM-5 PM
    (Saturdays by Appointment)

    Follow Us

    Get a Quote